I think that she should be forgiven even though he didn't go back and get all of the passengers he should still be forgiven. He saved him self and other passengers from dying, what about the ones who did live he saved like 700 people but for the ones who he didnt save was about 1,500. so yeah he couldnt go back and get everyone but he did save some people, I think he should be forgiven for his mistakes atleast he saved someone instead of no one at all, but thats just me I would forgive him.